White clapboard home entry with a charcoal glazed door, black-framed window, and gently weathered concrete porch in autumn afternoon light.

The Route 405 Detour Through Milton Has Lasted Since May. The Borough Finally Has the Keys.

The closed stretch of North Arch Street runs one block, from Broadway to Walnut Street. The detour PennDOT posted on the day it closed covers miles. It sends Route 405 traffic out Broadway, north on Route 147, onto Interstate 180 to Exit 1, and back down the Susquehanna Trail, also known as Route 1007. That loop is what one block of a state highway costs when the block can't be used.

The block has been closed since May 9, 2026, when the bell tower of the former church at 18 N. Arch St. partly collapsed. On Thursday, Oct. 15, Northumberland County Judge Frank Garrigan named Milton Borough conservator of the property. The street didn't reopen that day, and it still hasn't. The ruling did something more basic. For the first time since the collapse, the people who want the road open have legal control of the building that keeps it closed.

Why one building can shut a state highway

The building went up as St. John's Reformed Church. A local history compilation records the cornerstone being laid on Sept. 4, 1887, and the church being dedicated in 1895. CBS 21 covered the collapse the following day, May 10.

The road stays closed because of what's still standing. According to court documents described by The Standard-Journal, Gregory Decker, an engineer with Barry Isett and Associates, found "numerous loose and unstable brick units" around the edge of the collapse that "remain at risk of falling to the ground below." He also found damaged heavy timber framing behind the tower's louvers, missing mortar on all four sides of the top of the tower, and long-term moisture damage. His assessment said plainly that "Access to Arch Street should remain closed."

As long as those bricks can fall, the fall zone stays fenced. The fall zone covers a state route.

Who sits inside the fence

The closed block isn't empty. At the hearing, Borough Manager and Police Chief Curt Zettlemoyer testified that customers can't reach the front of The Standard-Journal's building, that its front dock has restricted access, and that the closure directly affects access to Speedy's Bar and Grill and Milton Developmental Services.

Milton Developmental Services runs a personal-care home in a building connected to the church, and administrator Patti Snyder told The Standard-Journal that the home's residents had to be relocated after the collapse.

The effects reached the rest of the calendar too. The borough said several Harvest Festival events had to be changed because of the closure, and PennDOT provided a traffic-control sign for the September festival. Zettlemoyer summed it up this way at the hearing:

"It's a clear danger. We have a main thoroughfare in the borough that is closed… There is a detour in the middle of town. It's a major inconvenience."

Five months of being locked out

Until Oct. 15, the borough's main tool was the citation.

The borough did cite it, 98 times between May and the hearing under the International Property Maintenance Code, according to code enforcement officer Alec Klingler's testimony. The Daily Item reported that the citations "led to no action" and that Klingler took no interior photos because the borough had no access. Without getting inside, a full evaluation of the damage was impossible.

The engineer did get inside once. His May 22 inspection happened after the borough obtained a search warrant. At the hearing, Zettlemoyer testified that church officials had said they don't have the money for the repairs and that the building isn't insured. Electricity and sewer service to the building have been shut off.

So the borough ended up holding the problem without holding the property. To change that, it filed under Pennsylvania's Abandoned and Blighted Property Conservatorship Act. The case is listed as Borough of Milton v. New Life Evangelistic Church, No. CV-26-1289, in the Northumberland County Legal Journal, and it asked for a conservator to take possession of 18 North Arch Street and rehabilitate or demolish it. The property owner testified at the hearing and did not object to the conservatorship.

What the ruling starts

Borough solicitor Michael Wiley explained the order to The Daily Item: it "allows the borough to have access to the property, evaluate the property and then make a suggestion to the court with a final plan on what should happen to the property."

Step Who handles it Status as of late October 2026
Full evaluation of the building Milton Borough, now with access Required, per Zettlemoyer
Put the work out for bid Milton Borough Required, per Zettlemoyer
Submit a plan for the property Milton Borough to the Court of Common Pleas Needs court approval before work begins
Secure the site and reopen Route 405 Borough and its contractor No date announced

Wiley told The Standard-Journal the borough will "work as quickly as we can" to secure the site and reopen the street. Nobody has said whether the building will be stabilized or taken down, and that decision belongs to the plan the court still has to approve. Judge Garrigan described the conservator's job as figuring out "what the fiscally responsible thing to do is," and added, "I appreciate the historic buildings. At a certain point, you have to see how far gone it is."

The money already set aside

For residents wondering who pays, the borough answered that question before it went to court. At its July 8, 2026 meeting, council authorized up to $220,000 from borough reserve funds to rehabilitate and secure 18 N. Arch St. The solicitor explained that the money wasn't being spent yet, but the authorization showed the court the funds were available.

Compare that with the engineer's "initial rough cost estimate" of $150,000, based on his May inspection. The gap between the two figures is $70,000. It's a cushion set aside before anyone had a full look inside. His recommended scope is narrow. It calls for taking the 20-foot bell tower down from the top, bracing the remaining walls, and adding a temporary roof and enclosure for weather protection. According to the court documents, the borough planned to use reserve funds and look for help from Northumberland County if it's available. Zettlemoyer told the court, "This is definitely something the borough did not prepare for when preparing our budget."

The downtown dates between now and then

No reopening date means the next stretch of downtown events will probably happen with the block still fenced. None of the events below has announced any changes tied to the closure.

  • Nov. 5 to 7: Salt & Light Theatre for the Performing Arts presents "A Little Off-Broadway: A Musical Revue with a Dash of Christmas" at Crossroads Nazarene Church, 71 Nazarene Lane.
  • Nov. 21: The Music and Mocktails series from T.I.M.E., The Improved Milton Experience, is on the calendar at Chef's Place, 139 South Front Street. The performer is still listed as TBD.
  • Dec. 4, 5 to 9 p.m.: Winterfest's Holiday on Broadway, at 55 Broadway Street, brings a Santa Toy Run, tree lighting, entertainment, food and craft vendors, live reindeer, and photos with Santa.
  • Dec. 5: Breakfast with Santa runs 9 to 11 a.m., location to be announced, and Santa's House on Broadway is open weekends through Dec. 20.

If you come to Broadway from the north side of town, plan on the detour for now. The court granted the conservatorship on Oct. 15, and a reopening date will only come once the borough's evaluation, bidding, and court-approved plan are done.

If the closure has you wondering how a property like 18 N. Arch St. fits into the rest of downtown Milton, or how an ongoing local issue might affect a home you own nearby, the team at Century 21 Colonial Real Estate is glad to talk it through with you. We follow these north-central Pennsylvania stories closely because our clients live with them every day. Contact Us.

Work With Us

We combine market knowledge, personalized attention, and a client-first approach to help buyers and sellers achieve their real estate goals with confidence.

Follow Us on Instagram